
NYC Liquid Eyeliner
Where to get it: Any drugstore.
Price: $3.00
The first product I tried was inexpensive enough for me to be willing to take a risk. Ok, it was downright cheap. The premise seemed good. It touted a "mistake free applicator" that seemed right up my alley. The eyeliner comes in a felt pen like package and has a felt type tip. Sounded fool proof to me.
Unfortunately, the tip is very long and this makes for less control when applying. Despite my most valiant of efforts, I once again ended up with the hated raccoon look. The eyeliner itself does have staying power, but if you can't apply it with control this actually works out to be a negative (as I learned). Unless you're quite handy with all things makeup, I wouldn't recommend this product.

Smashbox JET SET Waterproof Eye Liner
Where to get it: Beauty Boutiques like Sephora, Shoppers Drug Mart. Also online at Smashbox, and Amazon (link below).
Price: $22.00
After my failure with the NYC eyeliner, I once again gave up on the whole liquid liner idea. That is, until a good friend raved to me about a new product she tried. Smashbox JET SET waterproof eyeliner comes in a gel formula and can be painted on with a brush. The formula stays pliable for about a minute before becoming set and waterproof.
Because of the condensed consistency of the gel formula, I found it very easy to control the application of this eyeliner. I was actually able to apply it in a subtle way, and add more if I wanted to. The bottom line is that even a makeup flunkie like me can use this product and get a great result. It's on the expensive side, but well worth the money. I love it so much I have two! The brown and copper are my favourites, but a good friend has black and she swears by it.
One thing to note is that to use this eyeliner, you'll need a good eyeliner brush. More on that later.

Loreal HiP Colour Truth Cream Eyeliner
Where to get it: Any drug store.
Price: $11
As mentioned, I was so impressed with the Smashbox liner that I splurged on two colours. Since I don't have a huge amount of disposable income, I was interested in seeing if there was a less spendy offering out there.
I got a pleasant surprise in Loreal's HiP Colour Truth Cream Eyeliner. As the names states, the product comes in the form of a cream. It's slightly softer than Smashbox, so you have to be more careful with the application, but if you ensure that you don't load too much product on the brush it delivers a great result. The other bonus is that it comes with a great slant tipped brush. At half the cost of the Smashbox version it's a winner in my book.